What if we replace comet Elenin by brown dwarf?

June 3rd, 2011 |

What if we replace comet C/2010 X1 (Elenin) by brown dwarf with mass about 0.05 of Solar mass? This video demonstrate time interval from 2000 to 2020 years. As you can see, dramatic changes in the orbit of Saturn would have started 3 years ago. But at this time all planets are on it’s nominal orbits. I think myth about “brown dwarf instead comet Elenin” is debunked. You can see that by yourself.

Numerical integration was carried out by ORSA software using RADAU15-th order integrator.

Posted in News |

Tags: C/2010 X1 (Elenin), Comet, Comet Elenin, Комета, Комета Еленина

Thms

do you think comets are harmless dirty snowballs? from googling in the past week.. i have learned comets have a magnetic field, emit x-rays, contain antimatter and have antigravity.. http://www.ufodigest.com/article/hoteev-hypothesis-comets-contain-antimatter ”Pieces of comets containing cosmic antimatter would be very dangerous if they were to fall into the Earth’s atmosphere in comparison to meteorites made of matter. The Tunguska “meteorite” that fell in Siberia in 1908 is believed to be a comet. The explosion was estimated to be at an altitude of about 5 km. The recorded effects of the explosion were similar to that of a hydrogen bomb estimated to be equivalent to 20 to 50 megatons of TNT.” that article also had a interesting link http://science1.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2011/11jan_antimatter/ ”Click to view the three steps thunderstorms must take to produce bursts of anti-matter.” surprising what you find out on the internet..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Kheider Kevin Heider

Elenin made its closest approach to Saturn on 2008-Dec-20 @ 2.6587AU.
- Anonymous
  
  Ummm, interesting timing. An epic lightning storm started right after the closest approach [Jan 2009] and was still goin strong Sept 2009. Another coincidence?
  “Saturn Lightning Storm Breaks Solar System Record”
  http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2009/09/090915-saturn-lightning-storms.html
Anonymous

There was an epic [Solar System record breaker] lightning storm on Saturn during Elenin’s crossing of Saturn’s orbit. The epic lightning storm was first detected in January 2009 and was still raging in September.
Loagun

Well hello there NASA, I see your still pretending to be a Russian astronomer(of course there is that 0.00000001% chance Leonid Elenin is a real person, besides the fact a fake passport was presented in a Russian news piece trying to ‘prove’ his existence… taking lessons from Obama perhaps?… How about next time ‘Leonid Elenin’ actually is present in the news piece trying to show he is a real person…. That just seems like common sense to me? Then again I am from Canada, what do I know…). Aways, yeah. Saturn has been increasingly getting worse storm wise from 2006 – at the same time Comet Elein pulled into it’s neighbourhood coincidently…. For an astronomer your not that up to date – If your real – and NASA stop playing dumb. Your the ones that told us about Saturn’s crazy weather…. seriously, come on…. ugh.
Tony

bla bla bla blu blu blu…Guys make a better story!!! for best story there is a prize hehe … I guess if some english directors go through this site they will get new kind of story about earth killing events ..Guys with all respect whats use ? nothing..be calm earth will go on as good as much it can
http://www.facebook.com/people/Pavel-Smutny/100000762017672 Pavel Smutny

I made many simulations for Nibiru and more distant Nemesis in Winorsa,….6,..years ago. Your simulation is not prooper. Direction of X arrival is little other, X should come months later. There were simulations when our solar system stays during arrival of X nearly intact,…Don’t forget that X is not in our Sol. syst. only thousands years, but hundreed thousands, millions,…years. So everything should be very synchronised,…
- Anonymous
  
  I’m not simulate “X arrival’. Intergation was processed with nominal orbital
  elements for C/2010 X1.
Anonymous

You forgot name of current topic. My comet have very low inclination and I simulate massive object with orbital elements of my comet.
- Ulf Roald
  
  Indeed, from the data which I can found until now, your comet have just a unusually low inclination, what give strong arguments for your simulation. My apologize. How many degrees more exactly now? And in the period when was close with Saturn? I know, the comet wasn’t discovered yet at that time, but a estimate value?
  Sincerely,
Tuttle

There are no conspiracists that claim that Elenin is a brown dwarf! They don’t exist! This is just a secret operation of Chinese government to break our balls! *sigh*

Dear Leonid,I’m really sorry that these idiots even question your existence in their delusion. I hope you can stay calm. Unfortunately we have to wait a couple of months until they will finally shut up…
Aleksei

I’m from Russia. Personally it is not familiar with Elenin, but I can tell with the big confidence that it is the real person. But it does not change a situation
- Snorkelet
  
  I highly doubt Leonid Elenin is a real person and if he is, he did not discover the comet originally. Why? Because in Oct, 2010, the USA Government issued a document to the President stating that comets and all inbound material (asteroids, comets, meteors, etc) are considered top secret until all levels are briefed and discuss.
  
  Not only that, Leonid Elenin does not speak in Russian when writing. Take your post/comment, it sounds Russian. I can almost hear you talk. This is not the case with ANY of Leonid’s posts. He definitely has a native English tongue!!
Djmcbain4

That made the earths solar system look like a clock, my timid nerves felt uneasy at that, but at the same time, thanks for posting regularly the progress of your comet, the scared needing to be in control and protect my kids in me likes to read about elenin from a logical non radical person, you’d tell us if it becomes a threat right? hehe
Jef Jeffersons

Elenin,

I’ve got a question!

Is it possible that, that second sun (the twin sun) belonging to this galaxy does exist, but isn’t near the sun. And that the comet C/2010 X1, is just circling between those 2 suns, one may be the dwarf, the other one the sun.

Is it possible to verify the other end of the orbit of your comet?

Just a question… (Because i found the long orbiting comets interresting, if it returns here and then it leaves, then it should turn somewhere else back to here, it’s because of gravity it makes the turn here, but why shouldn’t it take the turn somewhere else also because of gravity)

Please respond,
Sincerely,
Jef Jeffersons

Elenin,

I’ve got a question!

Is it possible that, that second sun (the twin sun) belonging to this galaxy does exist, but isn’t near the sun. And that the comet C/2010 X1, is just circling between those 2 suns, one may be the dwarf, the other one the sun.

Is it possible to verify the other end of the orbit of your comet?

Just a question… (Because i found the long orbiting comets interresting, if it returns here and then it leaves, then it should turn somewhere else back to here, it’s because of gravity it makes the turn here, but why shouldn’t it take the turn somewhere else also because of gravity)

Please respond,
Sincerely,
- http://themathskeptic.blogspot.com The Math Skeptic
  
  No. It’s not possible.
Terry LE Mac

Nice work Leonid
NASCC

It makes sense that if you throw another star into the equation that something is going to go amiss.
NASCC

It makes sense that if you throw another star into the equation that something is going to go amiss.
John

Fantastic, great job, Elenin!
I could never imagine that an object only 5% of the Solar mass could cause such changes.
This is to do science, educating the people, but you saw that when people place more value on their own limiting beliefs, there is no way, is the same Herculean task to show little children who believe in fairy tales, the wicked witch does not exist.
John

Fantastic, great job, Elenin!
I could never imagine that an object only 5% of the Solar mass could cause such changes.
This is to do science, educating the people, but you saw that when people place more value on their own limiting beliefs, there is no way, is the same Herculean task to show little children who believe in fairy tales, the wicked witch does not exist.
John

Fantastic, great job, Elenin!
I could never imagine that an object only 5% of the Solar mass could cause such changes.
This is to do science, educating the people, but you saw that when people place more value on their own limiting beliefs, there is no way, is the same Herculean task to show little children who believe in fairy tales, the wicked witch does not exist.
John

Fantastic, great job, Elenin!
I could never imagine that an object only 5% of the Solar mass could cause such changes.
This is to do science, educating the people, but you saw that when people place more value on their own limiting beliefs, there is no way, is the same Herculean task to show little children who believe in fairy tales, the wicked witch does not exist.
Anonymous

You’re welcome!
Valhallasun

What is the total time frame of Comet Elenin’s total orbit of Earth? 1000 years? 10000 years? 100,000 years? Oh. yeah, we don’t know. Do we?

If it’s got a million year orbit, one would think that Elenin sure has a ton of spunk and fight.
All that time orbiting, in such a silly orbit, and so small, never really getting knocked off path.

It’s funny that humans really like to think they understand the universe and what is and isn’t in it, because they’re seen .00000000000000001 percent of it.

I don’t know what Elenin is, but it is a harbinger of sorts, if Elenin does no damage yet the global economic system collapses while it passes Earth, was it Elenin’s fault? lol
- Prince
  
  I know. Elenim is a comet.
- Prince
  
  I know. Elenim is a comet.
Anonymous

Period about 11800 years.
Lmwyld

one question 27 agust 2011 at what gmt hour?
- Anonymous
  
  Sorry, I’m not understand you.
Anonymous

I think comet Elenin had a massive stupidity field. Just look how it affected people!
Kylerh7655

Was Comet Elenin hit by an object? If so what hit Comet Elenin?
- Anonymous
  
  Nothing hit the comet.

M	T	W	T	F	S	S
« May				Jul »
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	19
20	21	22	23	24	25	26
27	28	29	30